So…
This weekend’s been an ordeal. Switching to the Macbook has, in many ways, been quite painless. Yeah, there’s some weirdness to be had, but for the most part, I’ve found it to be a great experience… with one glaring exception.
iPhoto fucking sucks.
Now, let me be absolutely clear – part of the problem is me. I screwed up the initial photo import, then tried to “fix” it in the wrong way. This will come back to haunt me later.
Basically, iPhoto takes all of your photos, and imports them into the iPhoto Library, copying all your photos into the library, unless you’ve selected an option in the preferences. So, because of the initial screwed up import, then the accidental duplication, I’d used up all the space on my hard drive. ‘That can’t be right,” I thought.
So, I went about trying to figure out how to get all the duplicates off the drive. “Wipe it all out and reinstall” would have been a great option, except at some point in the process, everything had appeared, momentarily, to be going right, so we imported a bunch of wedding photos off Ei-Nyung’s computer *and then deleted the originals*. Now, yes, this is stupid. Shut up. I already know.
So, we have three sets of photos, and one other. That last one is the last copy of those photos we have, so I *CAN’T DELETE THEM*.
So, I figure, okay, I’ll just go manually through iPhoto’s library, and delete all the duplicates by hand. Great. So, I do that. It takes about four hours.
Tonight, I go to spit out a slideshow in iDVD, and I can’t move some of the photos into the slideshow pane. Why? BECAUSE THEY DON’T FUCKING EXIST ANYMORE.
Here’s the problem. iPhoto creates thumbnails and picture info, and keeps that in some meta thing. They aren’t updated in real-time, so that you can browse through your photos without constantly refreshing everything. Great. But I did the initial delete of the original import I’d f’ed up, the thumbnails were left behind, along with the picture info.
When I went through and deleted all the dupes by hand, I’d checked a few of the groups randomly, and found that the right most photo in the list was good. So I went through the entire library, spot-checking, and deleting all but the right-most photo in the library pane.
Of course, what happened was that for almost every photo that I *didn’t* check by hand, and for NONE of the photos I did, they were the phantom remnants of photos that I’d already deleted. Thumbnails and picture info that didn’t know when to die.
So, now, I’ve gone through the iPhoto library, deleted every goddamn instance of the phantom thumbnails, and re-imported all of our existing photos, while leaving behind all the ones that looked alright.
Now, I’ve gotta go through and redelete a bunch of new duplicates. God, I can’t fucking wait.
While I like iPhoto for the first pass of photo editing (quick passes deleting the crap, comparing similar images and picking the better of the two, cropping, kicking the exposure up or down a stop or two), I don’t like using it to organize the pictures.
I have some 16k photos on my photo site, and have at least that many more that I’ve discarded. They’re in almost 600 hierarchical categories, and would quickly overwhelm the flat list of albums that iPhoto uses. And iPhoto has a history of crashing or getting unusably slow when the library gets too big.
So I just do my editing in iPhoto (using the “Edit in external editor” feature to drop into PS when necessary), then export the pictures to a folder on my hard drive, then scp that folder to my photo site. Every now and then I go in and clear out the iPhoto library, secure in the knowledge that my pictures are in standard formats on at least two disks.
I’ve been tempted to use Aperture or Adobe’s Lightroom, but I was really turned off by the Aperture UI, and the Lightroom Beta that I tried was too unfinished. It didn’t even have a crop feature at that point! It’s matured some since then, and I have been meaning to check it out again.
Good thing Macs can run Windows now 😉
Too bad Picasa doesn’t have a Mac install. People seem to love it on the PC. It doesn’t mess with your existing folders and/or layouts.
I remember immediately giving up on iPhoto on my brother’s Mac when he wanted the pictures I had taken from the cruise. Instead, I just copied over the files and said to him, “okay, now you deal with it.”